C# Feature Suggestion: Attaching Properties to Events

While working on the next version of the my Commonly Used .NET Coding Patterns in CodeDom article, I’ve come up with a nice idea for the next version of C# (or any other language for that matter).
Consider the following scenario:

A doctor’s office is handled by a class named DoctorsOffice. The class has a property of type PatientsQueue which is a queue of patients (First In, First Out), which in turn exposes an event called PatientEnteredQueue (which has one parameter – the Patient object). This event is called whenever someone walks in the door.
Some objects consume this event, such as the BlondeSecretary (who checks if the patient has an appointment) and the WeirdDudeWhosAlwaysThereForSomeReason (who just gives the new guy a weird sideways look).
Whenever a new patient enters the office, the PatientsQueue.Queue method is called which raises the PatientEnteredQueue event.
Once every few new patients, one of them asks the question “Who’s last in the queue?” just to know how long they’ll have to wait before seeing the doctor. This is implemented by the WhosLast property on DoctorsOffice.

class DoctorsOffice
    public PatientsQueue Queue { get; }
    public Patient WhosLast { get; private set; }

class PatientsQueue
    public void Queue(Patient p);
    public event PatientEvent PatientEnteredQueue;

A very logical approach to this would be to consume the event inside DoctorsOffice and set the WhosLast property to the Patient value. The problem here is that you would have to use a method in the middle, first to consume the event and then to set the property.

public DoctorsOffice()
    this.Queue.PatientEnteredQueue += this.AnotherPatientHasEntered;

private void AnotherPatientHasEntered(Patient p)
    this.WhosLast = p;

This is a cumbersome approach that can be bypassed by adding a simple feature – adding the ability to attach properties to events:

public DoctorsOffice()
    this.Queue.PatientEnteredQueue += this.WhosLast;

Since properties are implemented as methods, the compiler could choose which one it would like to use (depending on the signature of the delegate).
If the property returns an instance of the same delegate as the one being attached to, this would cause a problem and then C# 1.0’s syntax would have to be used, after a warning (the default would be to use the return value, rather than attach the property, for backwards compatability’s sake):

public delegate MyDelegate MyDelegate();

private MyDelegate MyDelegateEvent
        // Do work...

private void Foo()
    this.MyDelegateEvent += this.DelegateInstanceReturningProperty; // Warning. Return value used by default.
    this.MyDelegateEvent += new MyDelegate(this.DelegateInstanceReturningProperty);

4 thoughts on “C# Feature Suggestion: Attaching Properties to Events

  1. There is a recently developed tradition which essentially says that whenever someone makes an interesting suggestion about a powerful new feature for a .net language there must be either zero comments in response, or one person commenting simply to point out “ruby on rails already does that”.
    in breaking with tradition i’ll say that this seems like a nice idea.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s